Pdf female terrorists in isis, al qaeda and 21st century. The ideological and strategic differences between alqaeda and isis are reflected in a 2005 letter from the current leader of al qaeda ayman alzawahiri to the nowdeceased forefather of isis, abu. In the battle for global jihadist supremacy, isis now holds the upper hand, with al qaeda struggling just to fend off its own decline. A strategic history of hayat tahrir alshams formation. The war between isis and alqaeda for supremacy of the global. The key findings are that al qaeda and isis have fundamentally different ideological views about how to unite and purify the islamic. The al qaeda network today also comprises semiautonomous or self radicalized actors, who often have only peripheral or ephemeral ties to either the core cadre in pakistan or affiliated groups elsewhere. Al qaeda affiliate al shabab is suspected of detonating a suicide bomb in mogadishu, killing more than 500 people. Aqap and aqim eulogize zawahiri deputy abu alkhayr almasri, site intelligence group, march 2, 2017. The following excerpts are from a document found by the police in manchester, england, during a search of an al qaeda members home.
How alqaeda survived drones, uprisings,and the islamic state. The socalled islamic state, alqaeda and now the taliban are radical jihadist groups focused on ridding the world from the threat, as they perceive it, that western culture poses to islam however, although broadly speaking they share a similar ideology, their views actually differ significantly so much so that the three groups have often found themselves in conflict with one another. A comparative analysis of al qaeda and the islamic state is 3 globally. Thats how one expert explains why al qaeda members are defecting to isis, joining the thousands of. What ensued was a series of clashes between almourabitoun combatants now under the leadership of belmokhtar and sahrawi loyalists, which saw the latter. Al qaeda and isis have different approaches when it comes to interpreting and implementing key concepts such as alwala wa albara, takfir and jihad. Baghdadi rebranded the outfit as the islamic state of iraq and levant in april 20 freemen, 2014. The rise of al qaeda, which is a global actor, and the rise of isis influenced each other holbrook, 2015. Finally, the paper analyzes the key differences between the groups and explains how this information can be useful to operational planners. The roots of isis trace back to 2004, when the organization known as al qaeda in iraq formed.
The said organisations have been recognised under islamist extremism and declared as major terrorist groups by the united nations security council, european union and several other international security councils. Differentiating al qaeda and the islamic state through. Even when women do manage to break in, they are often limited in. The transformation of terrorism from al qaeda to the islamic state is has created new security challenges. Al qaeda al qaeda training manual inside the terror. In al qaeda, the islamic state, and the global jihadist movement. Alqaeda and the islamic state of iraq and levant isil are two globally termed terrorist organisations in the 21st century. Since the discussions have supposedly been between representatives of caliph albaghdadi of isis and al qaeda central aqc head ayman alzawahiri, in the interest of caution we should assume that the discussions are not just about a reconciliation in syria and iraq. Some reports indicate or claim that isis and al qaeda are discussing a merger. Speckhard 2015 female terrorists in isis, al qaeda and 21rst. The teaching of the reformers has been heterodox and revolutionary from the beginning. The objective of this thesis is to investigate al qaedas use of propaganda and to answer two major questions. Middle east and africa congressional research service summary after a more than a decade and a half of combating al qaeda aq in afghanistan and pakistan.
The war between isis and alqaeda for supremacy of the. The rise and fall of the islamic state of iraq and alsham. Byman, an eminent scholar of middle east terrorism and international security who served on the 911 commission, provides a sharp and concise overview of al qaeda, from its humble origins in the mountains of afghanistan to the present. Proceeding from the terrorists view of media as a critical arena of jihad, this study applies content analysis to al qaeda and islamic stateproduced magazines in order to empirically differentiate the two groups through the strategies. Shia, the iraqi and syrian regimes, and secular, pro. An assessmenty bruce hoffman the rand corporation, washington, d. This might lead to inadequate policies that deal with isis as a continuum of the threat from al qaeda, and would prolong rather than weaken, isis momentum. Isis and al qaeda pose an existential threat because they accelerate the collapse of world order, provoke domestic and global trends that endanger american values and way of life, and plan. Protesters, often with women in the lead, took to the streets demanding greater dignity, opportunity and politi cal. The document, which has since been described by the fbi as the.
After capturing large swaths of iraq and syria in 2014. In contrast to isiss stunning rise, al qaeda central, the previous leading group of global jihadism or sala. Destroying isis and al qaeda, report one frederick w. Pdf the transformation of terrorism from alqaeda to the islamic state is has created new security challenges. Difference between isis and al qaeda business insider. Since 20, al qaeda and isis have varied little in core ideology but have adopted divergent strategies and tactics. Apr 26, 2017 the islamic state group and al qaeda, long rivals for supremacy in the jihadi struggle, are feeling more pressure to combine as the islamic state loses its territorial base in syria and iraq and. The islamic state group and al qaeda, long rivals for supremacy in the jihadi struggle, are feeling more pressure to combine as the islamic state loses its territorial base in syria and iraq and. Difference between isis and al qaeda isis vs al qaeda. Alqaeda, its affiliated groups, associated groups, and adherents.
The dramatic split with isis did not represent the point of substantive change in alqaedas strategic thinking, however. While such strategies are different from alqaedas, experts and policymakers continue to neglect the divergences between the jihadisalafi principles of isis and al qaeda. Isis is primarily known for a series of videos showing beheadings of soldiers, civilians, journalists, and aid workers. Isis has ruled ruthlessly and killed with few restraints in its syrian holdings. The final break came with isis s recent expansion from iraq into syria, spurring al qaeda to disavow the group earlier this year. The emergence of the islamic state also known as isis, isil, or daesh transformed the world of jihadism. Aqap and aqim eulogize zawahiri deputy abu al khayr al masri, site intelligence group, march 2, 2017. This article explores how al qaeda and isis use the doctrines through an examination of the works of four key ideologues. Alqaeda affiliate alshabab is suspected of detonating a suicide bomb in mogadishu, killing more than 500 people. Al qaeda follows the same ideology as isis, fundamentalist sunni islam. Security council committee pursuant to resolutions 1267. The literature has been retrieved by manually browsing through more than 200 core and periphery sources in the field of. Although a troubled alliance, strategic differences between al qaeda and isis were not sufficient to cause the split.
Womens participation in terrorist groups varies from being completely blocked from participation to thirtypercent of membership in some groups. Between war and terrorism 363 francois gere 16 the united states confronting terrorism 398 arnaud blin 17 terrorism in southeast asiathreat and response 420 rohan gunaratna bibliography 435 contributors 445 index 447. Isil is officially known as the islamic state of iraq and syria, and isis for short. Al qaedas leading thinkers are steeped in these reformerslong struggle against the establishment. Though isis and al qaeda are now two separate organizations, isis recruiters seem to follow many of the same basic guidelines for luring people into their group and indoctrinating them. Al qaeda, the islamic state, and the global jihadist. The manual was found in a computer file described as the military series related to the declaration of jihad.
The results highlight the problems of treating both organizations as terrorist groups and contribute to debates on conceptually defining terrorism. The socalled islamic state, al qaeda and now the taliban are radical jihadist groups focused on ridding the world from the threat, as they perceive it, that western culture poses to islam. How alqaeda and islamic state differ in pursuit of common. How isis is challenging alqaeda in west africa institute. Harith alnadhari, a shariah law scholar with alqaeda in yemen, condemned the discord isis had stirred up between jihadi groups in syria, and their attempts to claim influence over other middle eastern and north african areas. Apr 29, 2015 yet even in its early days the group bickered with the al qaeda leadership. Bibliography alqaeda and its affiliated organizations universiteit. Security council committee pursuant to resolutions 1267 1999, 1989 2011 and 2253 2015 concerning isil daesh, alqaida, and associated individuals, groups, undertakings and entities.
Al qaeda and isis internet brainwashing manual business. This paper assesses current trends in terrorism and future potentialities. Government efforts against alqaeda, cna drm2017u015710final, august 2017. Introduction in early 2011, revolutions in egypt, tunisi a, libya and yemen heralded a new era of arab politics. Speckhard 2015 female terrorists in isis, al qaeda and. Kagan, kimberly kagan, jennifer cafarella, harleen gambhir, and katherine zimmerman al qaeda and isis.
The theory is that al qaeda instigated the attack, through its franchise in yemen, in order to reclaim its position as terrorist top dog from the arrivistes known variously as isil, isis and the. A leader of al qaeda in the islamic maghreb, a group with many longstanding ties to the iraqi jihad, declared his support for the islamic state and stated, we are still waiting for al qaeda. Isis the ruling to kill the americans and their allies civilians and military is an individual duty for every muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it, in order to liberate the alaqsa mosque and the holy mosque mecca from their grip, and in order for their armies to move out of all the lands of islam, defeated and unable to threaten any muslim. Al qaeda has sometimes capitalized on isis tacticsand made gains in unexpected ways. Although isis is different from al qaeda due to its demands for establishing a state, it. Sahrawis may 2015 oath of fidelity to isis, however, was swiftly rejected by belmokthar, who instead reaffirmed his and almourabitouns loyalty to alqaeda leader, ayman alzawahiri. While alshabab is an alqaeda affiliate, more than 200 fighters have defected since 2015 and declared allegiance to isis.
Al qaeda, the islamic state, and the global jihadist movement. Download pdf the recent insurgency in iraq has spawned fresh questions about what interests the islamic state of iraq and alsham isis represents and how exactly the organization relates to alqaeda. Al qaeda, trends in terrorism and future potentialities. The attached manual was located by the manchester england. Two al qaeda affiliates, al qaeda in the arabian peninsula aqap, and al qaeda in the islamic maghreb aqim, quickly issued a joint statement eulogizing al masri. Isis represents a new step, a new wave, in jihadism. Communicating terror an analysis of isis communication strategy an interview in december 2015 with the figaro, assael adary emphasised that.
Isis stands for the islamic state of iraq and syria or islamic state of iraq and alsham. This article examines the threats posed by these two groups by discussing their ideologies, structures and capabilities. In contrast, alqaeda groups have focused more on local populations and local flashpoints. The paper concludes by providing implications, limitations, and directions for future research. As al qaeda and the islamic state vie for ascendancy in the jihad movement, policymakers grapple with distinguishing the threat posed by these groups. Protesters, often with women in the lead, took to the streets demanding greater dignity, opportunity and politi cal pluralism. Socalled islamic state, the taliban, and al qaeda are all radical jihadist groups, but they are not all the same. The transformation of terrorism from alqaeda to the islamic state is has created new security challenges. The al qaeda manual the attached manual was located by the manchester england metropolitan police during a search of an al qaeda members home. The detailed name for the group in arabic is aldawla alislamiya fi aliraq wa alsham or the.
Al qaeda, its affiliated groups, associated groups, and adherents. The ideological and strategic differences between al qaeda and isis are reflected in a 2005 letter from the current leader of al qaeda ayman al zawahiri to the nowdeceased forefather of isis, abu. Alqaeda is a global militant islamist organization headed by osama bin laden. Indeed, although the groups have found tenuous common cause in military engagements such as iraq, their relations have been characterized by. While al shabab is an al qaeda affiliate, more than 200 fighters have defected since 2015 and declared allegiance to isis. It examines first the presumed state of al qaeda today with particular reference to its likely agenda in a postiraq war world. In his audio message on 8th april, he included jabhat alnusra jn as well, which is a terrorist organisation active in syria and affiliated to alqaida, as part of isis. Although the desired goal of an islamic state is the same for both political and militant islamists, there are.
Download pdf the recent insurgency in iraq has spawned fresh questions about what interests the islamic state of iraq and al sham isis represents and how exactly the organization relates to alqaeda. In contrast, al qaeda groups have focused more on local populations and local flashpoints. Kathleen hammerberg, alexander powell, zack gold, david knoll, and william rosenau, independent assessment of u. Government efforts against al qaeda, cna drm2017u015710final, august 2017. The base, the foundation, alternatively spelled alqaida and alqaida is a transnational extremist salafist militant organization founded in 1988 by osama bin laden, abdullah azzam, and several other arab volunteers during the sovietafghan war. The group is also known as daesh in the arabic language. Salafijihadi military organizations, particularly isis and al qaeda, are the greatest threat to the security and values of american and european citizens. Isis, al qaeda in talks for terror merger washington times. Two alqaeda affiliates, alqaeda in the arabian peninsula aqap, and alqaeda in the islamic maghreb aqim, quickly issued a joint statement eulogizing almasri. On a film released by the terrorists to al jazeera, a young chechen woman told the camera even if we are killed, thousands of brothers and sisters will come after us, ready to sacrifice. In his audio message on 8th april, he included jabhat al nusra jn as well, which is a terrorist organisation active in syria and affiliated to al qaida, as part of isis.
1329 286 496 1552 1161 1230 157 454 642 628 1189 1120 1032 1006 372 1396 511 509 231 1112 176 195 336 1320 1444 733 1021 1491 1454 1313 249 1300 398 57 143 735 1308 368 370 1195 1112 755